Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Naomi Alderman's avatar

Thank you for the piece on Gaza. It’s one of those ones where you forgive that it’s AI-written because the thoughts really are important.

I often think that my most outre political opinion is that both Palestinians and Israelis are human beings who deserve to live in peace and security. I’m not interested in making lists of who did what. Fundamentally, the babies and the toddlers in Israel and Palestine didn’t do anything to make this happen and they all deserve a better future than this.

The whole situation is being run by the extremist fringes who are absolutely addicted to the idea that just one more atrocity will guarantee success this time. There is on both sides an almost total unwillingness to recognise the real suffering on the other, as far as I can see. (And it’s QUITE far because my Hebrew is good and my Arabic is fair. One of the great unspoken tragedies of the world is how easy it is to learn Arabic if you have Hebrew and vice versa. The fact that almost no one does is a misery and a disaster.)

The situation doesn’t need any more people saying “I stand with x”. It needs a lot of countries to say: “We love both of you and are going to commit to guaranteeing your safety over the next 100 years while you figure out how to move through this to political solutions”. No one can come up with thoughtful generous ideas for peaceful coexistence while terrified for their children’s lives through bombs or military incursions.

Also Europe, which frankly started all this by not being willing to confront the horrors of how easily countries collaborated with Nazism, should be offering passports to anyone from Israel or Gaza who just wants to get out. Not visas. Passports.

Caroline CAS's avatar

What a treasure trove! I loved Giles Brandreth’s interview with Christina Baranski recently. Also loved the article about pathologising normal life. Today I am taking my newly turned 10 year old to get her ears pierced, she’s been up and dressed since 6am and is growing way too fast for my liking. My favourite bit right now though is having to pretend to scold her each night when I find her reading books under the blanket with her torch long after she should be asleep. Brings back memories of my mum doing the same. Now back to debating if I really need those black cos trousers……

80 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?